The Long-Islander News offers the full version as a traditionally printed newspaper.
Please click on the Subscribe to receive the paper weekly through the US Mail,
or click on the Newsstands to see where you can acquire single copies.

Board Called Back To Amend Or Defend Budget Amendments

By Peter Sloggatt

Huntington Supervisor Ed Smyth

Like students being told to show their work on a math exam, members of the Huntington Town Board are being told to prove their work on the recently adopted town budget, or change their answers.

The board on Tuesday approved amendments to Supervisor Ed Smyth’s 2027 proposed budget that, according to Councilwoman Theresa Mari, who proposed the changes, bring an 18-percent town tax increase to within the State-imposed tax cap.

“The amendments are a work of fiction worthy of a Pulitzer Prize,” Smyth said.

Smyth’s budget not only pierced the tax cap – this year set at 2.68 percent – but resulted in an 18-percent tax increase. Increased costs due to inflation and contractual obligations made it impossible to stay within the cap without cutting programs and services, he said.

He defended the plan during a lengthy and contentious public hearing earlier this month arguing it is a mathematical impossibility to stay within the cap without cutting services. In fact, he previously had released to the board members a spending plan that fell within the tax-cap guidelines. It cut every town department by 16 percent and eliminated programs like the Summer Arts Festival.

With a split vote, the board on Tuesday night adopted Mari’s amendments and adopted the amended budget.

Mari said she went through every spending assumption and every revenue estimate in the budget with two goals: no jobs eliminated and no services to residents eliminated.

To get there, the amendments increased the revenue side of the budget by counting $3.5 million in community project funding secured by Rep. Nick LaLota. The funding was approved by a vote of Congress, signed into law by the President, and not yet been delivered.

That’s not the problem, Smyth said. While he trusts the money will come through, it’s money earmarked for capital improvements and should be in the capital budget, not counted as general fund revenue.

Mari’s plan adjusted revenues and spending across numerous budget lines, including a $300,000 reduction in outside legal costs. Smyth took note of one upward revenue adjustment – a $25,000 increase in anticipated insurance settlements he said is arbitrary at best.

“It basically requires we have more accidents [in town vehicles], but doesn’t take into account that we’d have to pay that money to get the repairs done.”

Similarly, he notes an amendment that adjusts revenue from tipping fees at the town’s resource recovery facility does not account for the fact that under an intermunicipal operating agreement, the Town of Smithtown is entitled to 40 percent of those fees.

Mari’s amendments also tap the Town’s reserve funds, which Smyth said drops them to a level below state recommendations, and could result in lower credit ratings.

Councilmembers Dave Bennardo and Jen Hebert joined Mari in voting yes on the amendments. Smyth and Councilwoman Brooke Lupinacci both abstained from the vote.

“I didn’t have enough information,” Smyth said. “I was literally getting the resolutions as I sat down for the meeting.”

Two days later, after looking at the numbers, he called an emergency meeting for Friday morning.

“It’s about getting the math correct. Some of these amendments are defective,” Smyth said. “I’m offering them the opportunity to correct the amendments.”

State law requires the final budget be adopted by midnight, Friday.