HUNTINGTON
Suit Papers Swim In Drowning Case
Family of Greenlawn victim sues YMCA for compensatory and punitive damages
By Tricia Arend / tarend@longislandernews.com

The father of a 17-year old Huntington YMCA lifeguard who drowned earlier this year has filed a suit against the association and four of its employees.

In the suit filed in State Supreme Court on Sept. 11, Ray Dawson alleges the group’s failure to respond to the emergency situation in the pool in a timely and proper manner resulted in the death of his son Marc.

Glen Cove-based YMCA of Long Island, the overseer of the Huntington YMCA, Kaitlyn Wulfken, of Greenlawn, Adam Dworkin, of Northport, Georgene Howell, of Huntington, and Donna Porter, of Huntington, are named as the defendants in the suit.

Wulfken and Dworkin, two lifeguards on duty at the time of Dawson’s accident, were allegedly “reckless, careless and negligent in the life guarding and supervision” of the pool, the complaint states.

Howell, an aquatics coordinator, and Porter, a lifeguard, were both on the premises when the accident occurred.

The defendants were “reckless, careless and negligent in the ownership, operation, management, maintenance, control, lifeguarding and supervision of the subject premises” and failed to “take reasonable precautions to protect” persons using the swimming pool, the complaint alleges.

Wulfken, Howell and Porter did not return calls for comment as of press time and Dworkin could not be reached.

Michael Famiglietti, president and chief executive of the YMCA of Long Island, also did not return calls for comment as of press time.

The complaint further states that the defendants recklessly and negligently permitted and approved “a dangerous and life threatening activity” and failed to “administer proper, timely and adequate life saving techniques and skills.”

“Here’s a situation where you have a reckless disregard by the YMCA for the life, healthy and safety of Marc and the other members,” said Ray Dawson’s attorney Michael Perrotta, of Huntington.

Perrotta added that an investigation has revealed that the lifeguards on duty are “ill-trained, ill-experienced and inadequately prepared” to respond to an emergency situation of the nature of Marc’s Feb. 18 accident.

At the time of his accident police said Dawson, a Harborfields High School student, was known to practice holding his breath underwater on his breaks. When lifeguards at the pool looked in to check up on him, Dawson waved back to them and pointed to his watch to indicate he was still timing himself.

When they looked back just moments later, Dawson was unconscious. They pulled him out of the pool and began CPR. Dawson had been submerged for at least two minutes holding his breath, police said back in February.

Dawson was transported to Huntington Hospital and was later transferred to Long Island Jewish Medical Center, where he died on Feb. 25. He was unconscious during that time frame.

Perrotta said the family chose to file the suit requesting compensatory and punitive damages because they are convinced the YMCA let their son down on many levels.
“Their gross negligence caused the death of their son,” Perotta said. “They should be held accountable.”

Calls placed to the Dawson family were not returned as of press time.