FOODIE
Piccolo: World Class Dining Close To Home
By Pete & Karen / foodie@longislandernews.com

World class dining in an atmosphere of candlelight, mahogany and mirrors. Sounds like the perfect place for a romantic dinner for two… and it is. Piccolo, though, is so much more, and it seems that much of Huntington is already in on the secret.

Piccolo is the flagship of three dining spots owned by restaurateur Dean Philippis, and easily the most elegant. Since opening Piccolo at the site of the former Great Dane restaurant 20 years ago, Philippis has since bought the Mill Pond House in Centerport and Sweet Mama’s, a casual breakfast-through-late night spot for home style cooking in Northport. Tucked in the Southdown shopping center on north Wall Street in Huntington, Piccolo’s dark woods, trompe l’oeil murals and crisp white linens lend an immediate atmosphere of class and coziness. There’s a reason the dining room has so many tables for two. Yet a lack of haughtiness and world class cooking – yes, we did say world class – have made Piccolo a favorite place for families and friends to gather.

The menu starts Italian – but goes wherever the chef’s market-driven fancy takes him. But mostly it’s customer driven, Philippis says, and comfort-seeking regulars are often likely to order a simple platter of the housemade linguine with a marinara sauce and a $250 bottle of wine to go with it, while his dining companion tries something more adventuresome.

On our recent visit, we took plenty of time to look over the menu – including a lengthy list of specials recited by our server. A hallmark of Piccolo, the service staff are all experienced with some there as long as Dean has owned the place. Neftali was attentive and cheerful, while Georgi charmed us with his humor. He trilled his way through the specials, rrrrrrolling his ‘R’s with such skill, we made him repeat the “Rrrrrroast duckling with rrrrraspberry sauce,” just to hear him do it again.

So varied were the choices, we polished off most of a basket of crusty bread — with extra virgin olive oil for dipping — before ordering, and then went with the house suggestions.

We started with the Montauk Diver Sea Scallops ($13) baked in a white wine and butter sauce. The sweet tender scallops were brined with a touch of caviar and served with artichoke hearts and microgreens. Elegantly resented in a large scallop shell, they earn an extra star for presentation. Arugula salad with dried cranberries, pungent blue cheese, pignoli nuts and crispy wontons ($12) was refreshing, with an Asian tang.
Baked clams oreganata or casino ($10) – fresh and plump – are capably handled at Piccolo. Next trip back we’re going for the Mission Figs and Goat Cheese ($13) with prosciutto and melon, and Fried Calamari Fra Diavolo ($13). And if we ever win Lotto, we’ll let you know how that $135 an ounce Osetra Caviar is.

Pasta dishes encompass a range and after sampling two, we understand that linguini marinara with the $250 wine order. Linguine alle Vongole ($20) – Littleneck clams, white wine, garlic and olive oil – is light, fresh and simple. It contrasted with the soulful, earthy flavors of the Braised Short Rib Cannelloni ($24), a deeply textured cannelloni stuffed with slow cooked beef, peas and mushrooms and topped with a truffle cream sauce.

Main courses are an equally rich adventure. We’re told that duckling – twice roasted and served with raspberry sauce ($26) is a house specialty, as is anything seafood. A thick cut of Chilean Sea Bass ($28) from the specials list was a vibrantly colored presentation with deep green baby spinach, red dried tomatoes, and long-stemmed artichoke that tasted every bit as good as it looked.

Also recommended, Pork Chop Milanese ($24), a variation on the veal favorite with chopped arugula, tomato, artichoke hearts and capers; Salmon Filet ($28) with a lump crabmeat crust; and Shrimp Piccolo ($28), jumbo shrimp with artichoke hearts, because one can never go wrong when the house puts its name on a dish.

Throughout the parade of food, service was attentive, though not obtrusive, and despite the inherent class of the establishment, was friendly and familiar in all the right places. Piano accompaniment from the lounge area was a delightful addition, as was the company. At adjacent tables sat a well known orthopedist and his wife, and at another, a Supreme Court Judge. Conversation went back and forth between our three tables, as did a portion of out dessert, a rich, flourless chocolate cake and a tummy warming Banana Bread Pudding.

The familiarity of the faces, the servers and the surroundings work in Piccolo’s favor. We felt welcomed by all.

Piccolo Restaurant of Huntington
215 Wall Street, Huntington
631-424-5592
www.piccolorestaurant.net

Atmosphere: Elegant and romantic, yet comfortable
Cuisine: Creative New American
Price Range: Expensive
Hours:
Dinner: Sunday: 4-10 pm, Monday-Thursday: 5-10 pm,
Friday - Saturday: 5-11 pm


Main Menu

Invite The Foodies: Submit news and notices of upcomming events to The Foodies, c/co Long Islander Newspapers, 149 Main Street, Huntington, Ny 11743 or email foodie@longislandernews.com. To suggest a review call Peter Sloggatt at 631-427-7000
  WEEKLY DELIGHTS
•  Aunt Rosie
•  Police Report
•  Obituaries
•  Community Calendar