FOODIE

Bonwit Inn Boasts Classic Tastes
By Alessandra & Luann/foodie@longislandernews.com


If you’re looking for a place to stay for a couple of nights, Bonwit Inn of Commack is not the place to go. But, if you’re looking for a wonderful place to eat for a night out on the town, well, that’s a different story.

The Bonwit Inn is just as rustic and romantic inside as it is on the outside, but don’t be fooled by the name. Although people may want to walk up the brick pathway to the entrance of the restaurant, toting behind them a suitcase or two, it is not for lodging. The origin of the restaurant’s name remains a mystery even to Bonwit’s current owner, who simply kept the name bestowed on it by its previous owners.

When we first walked inside, we were met by a smiling staff. But behind them was even more to grin about. Awaiting us was an array of rooms decorated with wood carvings on the moldings and an Old World stone fireplace that gave us as warm a feeling inside as it would have on the outside had it been on.

Bonwit’s menu encompasses all the standards of pasta, seafood and meat, with a few extra delights. Before we ordered, a plate of hot bread came to the table with whipped butter that melted as soon as it touched the warm dough. Next came the complimentary and refreshing Greek salad given to each table before dinner for guests to share.

We started off with two appetizers, the baked clams ($8), and fresh mozzarella ($8). The Baked Clams, a “Bonwit classic,” are made special at Bonwit, restaurant staff said, though they wouldn’t reveal the secret recipe. They were deliciously plump and tasty. The mozzarella was paired with prosciutto, vine ripe tomatoes and roasted peppers in a balsamic glaze. The tangy taste of the mozzarella made it irresistible – the taste of the balsamic stuck to the mozzarella like water to a sponge, and the mozzarella’s taste stuck to the tomato, and so on. Other appetizers, such as the Clams Casino ($9) and Fried Calarmari ($9), served with spicy garlic-tomato sauce, also caught our eye. They even had Roasted Beets ($8) layered with goat cheese, candied walnuts, arugala and cider glaze.

Completion of our appetizers left us that much closer to the satisfaction of our main meals, which included the Seafood Fra Diavolo ($28) and the Pecan Crusted Chicken ($19), both popular dishes. The impressive and generous seafood platter was filled with a lobster tail, shrimp, scallops, calamari, mussels and clams in a spicy garlic tomato sauce over linguini. The chicken entrée was pan-seared and finished with a pineapple citrus glaze, leaving you this taste that leaves you wanting more for weeks after. It came with apple compote and whipped potatoes on the side.

Other dishes we hope to try include: the Veal Windsor ($24), which is sautéed scaloppini garnished with jumbo shrimp in a chardonnay wine sauce with fresh herbs and tomato; Chilean Sea Bass ($27), which is pan seared and oven roasted in a chardonnay beurre blanc with spaghetti squash, julienne zucchini and whipped potatoes; the Bonwit Seafood Special ($30) with a lobster tail, stuffed shrimp, sea scallops, baked clams, filet of bass, salmon, and Maryland crab cake served in a white wine sauce; and the Rack of Lamb ($30), which is roasted herb and mint crusted rack of lamb with au jus.

Only one more thing was left for us to try: dessert! Every dessert on the menu is $6 and the list of choices was tempting. We ended up going for the Chocolate Tartufo, which is chocolate and vanilla ice cream with a raspberry middle covered in scrumptious chocolate, and the Parfait, which is layers of chocolate mousse, custard, chocolate pudding and pralines. A long, decorative thin piece of chocolate stuck out of the tall parfait glass. If you aren’t the one eating it, you will definitely be jealous of who is.
Part of Dine Huntington Restaurant Week next month, Bonwit Inn also does catering and has private rooms for parties. The restaurant is quite spacious; the main floor can seat up to 275 guests, whereas 140 guests can be seated upstairs. There are always new people and regulars coming in and out of the doors, and funny enough, they sometimes have luggage with them, the manager said.

So whether you’re with your flame or just a group of friends, this place is one where you definitely leave happy. Just remember to bring your appetite, and leave the suitcases behind. Also check out the marvelous Sunday brunch.



Main Menu

Invite The Foodies: Submit news and notices of upcomming events to The Foodies, c/co Long Islander Newspapers, 149 Main Street, Huntington, Ny 11743 or email foodie@longislandernews.com. To suggest a review call Peter Sloggatt at 631-427-7000
  WEEKLY DELIGHTS
•  Aunt Rosie
•  Police Report
•  Obituaries
•  Community Calendar