FOODIE
A Fresh Escape From Winter’s Cold
By Danny Schrafel/ foodie@longislandernews.com

If your restaurant serves you a salad with good tomatoes in January, chances are you’ve made a wise decision.

Commack’s Olio, at 5990 Jericho Turnpike in Commack, did just that with our Calamari Ginger Salad ($9.99), which comes with lightly fried calamari, romaine, walnuts and diced plum tomatoes tossed in a mild homemade ginger dressing. Along with the tender calamari in buttery, crunchy batter and crisp romaine, the ripe tomatoes create a delectable contrast of hot and cold, salty and sweet, crisp and crunchy.

The eatery, great for lunch and dinner alike, promises “good wine, good friends and good times,” and we agree. It’s also a wonderful place to shake off the sub-20-degree winter chills, with its calming, wood-and-brick interior and musical selections that range from Rat Pack to legendary Italian opera.

Olio is part of an extended family of restaurants like Commack’s La Spada and Stony Brook’s O Sole Mio.

After our salad, we decided to explore that magnificent pizza case, stocked with rolls ($5.99), pinwheels ($2.99), stromboli and calzones ($4.99 - $5.99), and pizza galore. A regular is $12.95 for the whole pie, but with their emphasis on fresh ingredients, we’d advise being adventurous and indulging – your choices range from simple marinara ($10.95) to indulgent stuffed meat ($27.95) and chicken francese ($20.95) or Gorgonzola salad ($19.95.)

The pinwheels are also worth noting as possibly the best $3 you can spend in sheer bang-for-your-buck. They’re stuffed with mozzarella cheese and other Italian goodies like spinach, broccoli, sausage or pepperoni. More filling than the price tag would betray, the doughy, cheesy confections are served with a side of piping-hot marinara sauce. The mammoth, almost imposing rolls would likewise be a great choice as they pull from the same source materials.

Check out the soup, too, which includes minestrone, stracciatella and pasta e fagioil; each runs $4.50 for a small, $7 for large. Add meatballs to stracciatella, a spinach and egg-drop consommé, for a nominal charge.

With the economy still in the tank, Monday and Tuesday pasta nights might make dining out easier, offering diverse entrees, soup or salad, a beverage and dessert for less than $15. Also, note that pies are $2 off on Wednesdays.

Just as we paid up for our second round, they put a tray full of heros, stuffed with chicken, fresh mozzarella, peppers, sausages – you name it – right under our noses under the glass. Looks like our new year’s resolutions may be in more danger than we thought.

Olio Ristorante & Pizzeria
5990 Jericho Turnpike
Commack
631-858-9898
www.mangiaolio.com

Cuisine: Italian staples, with an emphasis on freshness

Atmosphere: Cozy, calming eatery

Price Range: Inexpensive – Moderate

Hours: Sun. – Thurs. 11 a.m. – 10 p.m.
Fri. & Sat. 11 a.m. – midnight



Main Menu

Invite The Foodies: Submit news and notices of upcomming events to The Foodies, c/co Long Islander Newspapers, 149 Main Street, Huntington, Ny 11743 or email foodie@longislandernews.com. To suggest a review call Peter Sloggatt at 631-427-7000
  WEEKLY DELIGHTS
•  Aunt Rosie
•  Police Report
•  Obituaries
•  Community Calendar