FOODIE

Stuffed To The Gills At Legal Sea Foods
By Luann & Lou / foodie@longislandernews.com

The food philosophy at Legal Sea Foods is not like that of any other place we’ve ventured recently. The Legal Sea Foods group says it is not a restaurant selling fish. Rather, it is a fish company in the restaurant business.

Located at the south end of the Walt Whitman Mall, Legal Sea Foods is where fresh is the name of the game and skimping on quality and portions is not an option. The chain’s roots lie in Massachusetts where, in 1968, the Berowitz family opened their first seafood restaurant in the legal district right next to the family’s fish market. Now under the leadership of Roger Berkowitz, Legal Sea Foods operates 30 restaurants, about half of which are in the Boston area; the Huntington Station one opened in 2000.

High ceilings and waterfall structures amidst sea greens and calming, pleasant blues provide a soothing, open atmosphere for Legal’s patrons.

We took a seat for a Friday lunch among a decent mix of shoppers and business people and perused the lunch menu as we sipped on refreshing homemade pomegranate lemonade ($3.50). We were told that, while many dishes at the different Legal Sea Foods restaurants are prepared more or less the same, chefs have the opportunity to experiment with the specials and lunch creations. The lunch menu offered tremendous flexibility, both in choice and price, from the raw seafood bar, tuna burgers and lobster rolls to salads and smaller versions of typical dinner entreés.

Our waiter Christian started us off with a duo of warm, creamy soups to wake our palate. We wished the Clam Chowder ($4.50 cup/$6.50 bowl) came in a never-ending bowl. The clams come tender and plump, not chewy in the slightest, with just the right amount of potatoes and celery so that the vegetables don’t take over the soup. The Lobster Bisque ($6.95/$9.95) is just as tasty. The bisque comes in a pitcher and is poured into a cup over pieces of lobster right before your eyes.

Next up for us was a pair of standout appetizers. Steamed Shrimp Wontons ($8.95) come stuffed to the brim alongside seaweed salad. We were so impressed by how well prepared they were that we had to ask general manager Adam Bernstein the secret, which apparently is “the wonton lady” – the woman behind the magic whose sole job it is to make the wontons.

For all your calamari crazies out there, the Crispy Montauk Calamari ($10.95) should be right up your alley. We sampled the trio – a combination of regular batter dipped, Thai style and Rhode Island style. Tender does not even begin to describe how perfectly cooked all are. Thai style calamari come drenched in a tangy sweet and spicy sauce with peanuts and bursts of pineapple. Rhode Island style calamari sits in garlic butter topped with hot cherry peppers and pickles. Picking a favorite of the three would have been impossible.

Our entreés started with the Cajun Swordfish Taco Salad with tortilla strips, tomatoes, avocado, sour cream, cilantro and ranch dressing ($13.95). We tipped our hats to chef Tim Molinari on this one; the salad stayed crisp and fresh, and the swordfish nice and juicy with a delicate kick.

The lunch Crab Cake ($15.95) has so much meat it in it seems more like a crab meat cocktail than a crab cake. Made with almost 80 percent crab and baked – not fried – tasting the difference is easy. Not overcome with bready filling and an overabundance of spices, you can actually savor the taste of the crab.

The grilled Mediterranean Salmon ($15.95) is served like none we’ve ever had, topped with a garlicky hummus and a side of cucumber yogurt sauce with orzo and crisp pita wedges.

Even Legal Sea Foods’ seasoned fries drew us in, but after the meal we had, this did not surprise us.

Dessert consisted of – what else? – Boston Cream Pie ($5.95), with cake on the bottom and smooth custard-like cream, topped with a delicate chocolate layer and dusted with cocoa powder. Key Lime Pie ($6.50) is the real thing.

Showing that they’re a major restaurant with a “mom and pop’s attitude,” Legal Sea Foods is sinking its roots into the community with a family friendly attitude. The children’s menu has everything from lobster to macaroni and cheese, and they even have a special menu for patrons with gluten allergies. Legal Sea Foods also donated 15 gallons of chowder in the Macy’s Shop For a Cause event.

You can bet your bottom dollar we’ll be back, at the very least to take advantage of the three course Lobster Lover’s Dinner – for $32.95, you get a cut of clam chowder, a 1-1/2 pound lobster, and key lime pie. We may even call Legal Sea Foods for our home lobster bake or clambake, if we get around to hosting one, because yes, they do that too.

 


Legal Sea Foods

Walt Whitman Mall
160 Walt Whitman Road
Huntington Station
631-271-9777

Cuisine: Seafood

Atmosphere: Comfortable yet sophisticated

Hours: Mon-Thu 11:30 a.m. - 10 p.m.
Fri-Sat 11:30 a.m. – 11 p.m.
Sunday noon - 9 p.m.



Main Menu

Invite The Foodies: Submit news and notices of upcomming events to The Foodies, c/co Long Islander Newspapers, 149 Main Street, Huntington, Ny 11743 or email foodie@longislandernews.com. To suggest a review call Peter Sloggatt at 631-427-7000
  WEEKLY DELIGHTS
•  Aunt Rosie
•  Police Report
•  Obituaries
•  Community Calendar